Skip to content

Is the tension between 'operate while consulting' and 'suspend until consulted' still alive?

According to the cited documentsSocial licence

Yes. The Oxec line (2017) allowed operation while consulting; the Escobal (2018) and Fénix (2020) lines suspended until consulted; and in August 2025 the Supreme Court (CSJ) granted amparo to communities in San Mateo Ixtatán and ordered consultation without halting the hydropower plant (headline verified; text to be extracted). Without a law there is no stable rule: each judgment redefines the procedure case by case.

Read moreRead less

Sources

The documents this answer cites, by publisher, with the date each one was consulted and a link to it.

  • Prensa Comunitaria

    Ago-2025, CSJ ampara a comunidades y ordena consulta pero no detiene hidroeléctrica en San Mateo Ixtatán

    In Spanishprensacomunitaria.orgAccessed Aug 19, 2026Go to the source
  • MEM

    Sentencia Oxec y Oxec II

    In Spanishsite.mem.gob.gtAccessed Aug 19, 2026Go to the source
  • Observatorio Principio 10

    Sentencia CC Guatemala Ex

    observatoriop10.cepal.orgAccessed Aug 19, 2026Go to the source
  • Texto de la sentencia CC Ex,

    Texto de la sentencia CC Ex, vía nimajpu.org

    In Spanishnimajpu.orgAccessed Aug 19, 2026Go to the source